Do First Responders Have Liability in the Event of an Accident?

Spread the love

The aftermath of an accident involving first responders may be highly complicated because of the various legal safeguards to limit their liability. These safeguards, sometimes known as sovereign immunity, absolve parties of responsibility in certain situations such as car accidents. Each state, though, has restrictions that invalidate this protection. For instance, sovereign immunity might not be applicable if a first responder caused a vehicle collision due to negligence (i.e., failing to activate sirens or flashing lights).

But before determining who was at fault, the emergency’s severity will be considered if the accident happened then. Suppose a severe crisis was present at the time of the accident. In that case, the first responder could not be liable, leaving you responsible for paying for your medical bills and property damage.

The good news is that Personal Injury Protection (PIP) Insurance is available to all drivers in the United States. PIP offers compensation for lost wages, up to a specific level, funeral costs, and hospital expenditures in the event of a fatality resulting from an auto accident. Car accident lawyers can help you in better ways when first responders have liability in the event of an accident or not.

Statistics for First Responder Vehicle Crashes

The United States Fire Administration (USFA) lists automobile accidents as the second most common reason for on-the-job fatalities among firefighters. Additionally, compared to ordinary citizens, first responders have a fatal accident involvement rate that is 4.8 times higher.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has reported the following information:

  • Each year, around 6,500 accidents involve ambulances.
  • 35% of these collisions were deadly or resulted in serious injury
  • A passenger vehicle’s occupants made up 63% of those who died in incidents involving ambulances, ambulance passengers made up 21%, ambulance drivers made up 4%, and pedestrians made up 12%.
  • About 60% of ambulance accidents happen when used in an emergency
  • Emergency medical personnel are more prone to cause accidents among first responders.

Who Is Responsible for This Kind of Situation?

Liability typically rests with the one that behaved negligently the most. As a result, each claim’s outcome will be determined case by case. The context of the event and a number of other factors will be taken into consideration while determining culpability. For instance, the first responder might not be liable if the collision happened when an emergency vehicle was traveling to a severe emergency. Emergency personnel, however, are responsible for considering the safety of other cars on the road and must operate their vehicles properly.

First Responder Compensation Claims for On-Duty Injuries

The following are some of the more frequent ways that first responders may suffer harm:

  • Injuries can be particularly severe for EMTs and paramedics, who may be carefree while treating a patient in an ambulance because first responders are not required to obey specific traffic laws when responding to an emergency. As a result, they may be hurt in collisions at speeds significantly higher than in a typical car accident.
  • First responders may be especially vulnerable to slip-and-fall incidents if the property owner has not taken reasonable precautions to make the site safe because they frequently have to enter people’s homes or business establishments in dangerously dark environments.
  • Unsafe circumstances that property owners have left behind. First responders have the legal right to enter a person’s property with the expectation that the premises would be reasonably safe when they do so. Property owners must make their property reasonably safe for those who enter with permission.
  • Lifting significant, hefty things In their work, first responders might have to lift a patient or other essential items, which frequently leads to injuries, especially over time.
  • When a first responder arrives at the scene of a fight, he or she can get hurt by the drunk or belligerent individual who started the fight or gets trapped in the middle of one.
  • Exposure to chemicals and smoke. Police officers occasionally have to enter hazardous locations where narcotics are produced, and law enforcement personnel and firefighters frequently risk being exposed to fire.
  • Although post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is relatively common in those who have experienced horrific or dangerous situations. Since first responders frequently do, it might be one of the more challenging jobs, given the incidence of PTSD.

Commercial Vehicle Categories Involved in Accidents

Vehicles described as CMVs by United States Code 31132 include those that are as follows:

  • 10,001 pounds and more
  • Designed to carry at least 16 passengers
  • Created to move specific hazardous compounds

For commercial purposes, CMVs typically transport equipment, goods, or people. Typical illustrations of CMVs include:

  • Semi-trucks, tractor-trailer trucks, and 18-wheelers
  • Vans and trucks for delivery
  • Trucks for recycling and garbage
  • Truck dumps
  • Tow vehicles
  • Coaches and buses
  • Vehicles used in construction and landscaping

Any of these vehicles could result in severe damage in a collision due to their size and the cargo they often carry. For example, traumatic brain injuries (TBIs), spinal cord injuries, shattered bones, and internal bleeding could all result in long-term or even fatal damage.

Acts of Negligence That May Lead to CMV Accidents

Most of the time, when operating these vehicles, the drivers are working. However, even experienced professional drivers are prone to making careless errors that result in collisions. The fact that they are working in some circumstances raises the possibility of a mistake. For instance, they might have been moving quickly to achieve their delivery deadlines or quotas.

For the maintenance and operation of these vehicles, CMV operators and trucking companies must adhere to state safety laws. This comprises the following:

  • Maintaining a current commercial driver’s license (CDL)
  • Observing the Federal Motor Carrier Safety Administration’s (FMCSA) set hours-of-service restrictions (FMCSA)


A commercial motor vehicle (CMV) accident such as a bus or semi-truck is also known as a CMV accident. The occupants of passenger vehicles frequently sustain serious injuries when struck by commercial vehicles. Because they are typically bigger and heavier than smaller cars, trucks, SUVs, and CMVs generally cause this type of accident. Many also transport bulky or dangerous items.

Traumatic or fatal injuries are conceivable in collisions at relatively low speeds. If you or a member of your family were involved in a CMV accident, you might be able to recover damages from the driver, their employer, and other parties.

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Subscribe to receive the weekly Newsletters from our website. Don’t worry, we won’t spam you.